BROKER COMPARISON / COLUMN

Forex ECN Account Comparison: Commissions, Spreads and STP

Compare ECN-type accounts at 10 forex brokers: commission units, spreads, minimum deposits and total cost against commission-free accounts (14 Nov 2026).

The name ECN is shared, but commission units and spread wording differ by broker.

All 10 brokers we list offer an account with a trading commission, yet on the official pages we read, 3 of them, INFINOX, Vantage and Monaxa, use the word ECN.

You will be able to put commissions on one scale and calculate the total-cost gap yourself.

Conclusion: compare ECN-type accounts by total cost, commission included

Diagram: a commission-free account costs the spread; a commission account costs a tighter spread plus commission
  • A commission account is compared by its near-zero spread plus the per-lot commission
  • The name ECN does not tell you whether commission applies. Some commission accounts are not called ECN
  • Commission is quoted one way, round trip or per amount traded. Convert to round-trip USD before comparing
  • On one standard EUR/USD lot, a $6 round-trip commission equals a 0.6 pip spread

We checked the official pages of 8 of the 10 brokers we list (all except HFM and XM) on 14 November 2026. DecodeFX is shown with the terms of accounts opened via this site.

For HFM, we use the account comparison screen (captured 29 October) and the commission figure verified on 1 September. For XM, we use the account types screen (captured 29 October) and the figure verified on 10 August.

A comparison of terms, not a ranking

Rows follow our listing order, not quality. Where an official page shows no figure, we write "not stated".

Editorial conclusion

The more you trade, the more the commission matters. Before choosing, compare the account with the same broker's commission-free account on spread plus commission.

Commission accounts at 10 brokers, side by side

Table of the official commission and spread wording at XS, XM, HFM, Axi and Vantage

Commission and spread are shown in each broker's own wording, units included.

DecodeFX is the exception: it uses the setting via this site. The official PRO page shows $5 round trip, a difference that comes from IB contract terms.

Table of the commission and spread wording at DecodeFX, INFINOX, Monaxa, Exness and AXIORY
Commission accounts as shown (checked 14 November 2026)
Broker and accountCommission as shownSpread as shown
XS Elite6$ round trip, charged in one sum when the position is openedAverage 0.1 (EURUSD)
XM Zero$10 per $100,000 traded (checked 10 August 2026)Tightest 0 pips
HFM ZeroFX $6 round trip per standard lot (checked 1 September 2026)From 0, on FX pairs
Axi Premium$4.5 round tripEURUSD 0 pips
Axi Elite$3.5 round tripEURUSD 0 pips
Vantage ECNJPY 900 (USD 6) round trip per lotFrom 0.0 pips
DecodeFX PRO (via this site)$7 per standard lot (checked 4 August 2026)From 0.0 pips
INFINOX ECNCommission applies (no amount on the official comparison table)From 0.2 pips
Monaxa ZeroCommission (one way) $3.50From 0.0 pips
Exness Raw SpreadUp to USD 3.50 one way per lotFrom 0.0 pip
Exness ZeroFrom USD 0.05 one way per lotFrom 0.0 pip*
AXIORY NanoUSD 6 round trip (1 lot)Official cost example: USD/JPY 0.2 pips
AXIORY ZeroPer pair, round trip: EURUSD USD 8.7, USDJPY USD 9.90.0 pip about 90% of the day on specific FX pairs

※ AXIORY says Zero account commissions may be adjusted slightly with market conditions.

"From", "average" and "tightest" are different figures

"From 0.0 pips" is the best case, not a constant. XS shows an average and XM shows the tightest figure.

Minimum deposit and platforms (checked 14 November 2026)
Broker and accountMinimum deposit (Axi: first deposit)Platforms
XS Elite500 USDMT4, MT5
XM ZeroFrom $5 (checked 10 August 2026)MT4, MT5 and others
HFM Zero$0 / €0 / ¥0MT4, MT5
Axi Premium / EliteFirst deposit $500 / $25,000MT4, MT5
Vantage ECN50 USDMT4, MT5
DecodeFX PROUSD 100MT4, MT5, WebTrader, APP
INFINOX ECNNot stated on the official comparison tableMT4, MT5
Monaxa Zero$200MT4, MT5
Exness Raw Spread / ZeroFrom USD 200 (varies by region)MT4, MT5
AXIORY Nano / ZeroNo per-account figure (per-method minimums only)MT4, MT5, cTrader

"ECN" means different things at different brokers: check the official wording

Numbered INFINOX official comparison table: the ECN account has commission, the STP account starts from 0

On the official pages we read, 3 of the 10 brokers we list use the word ECN: INFINOX, Vantage and Monaxa.

INFINOX and Vantage each have an account named ECN. Monaxa's account list labels the Zero account "ECN" execution.

Table of account names and commissions: INFINOX ECN and STP, Vantage ECN and Premium and Monaxa Zero

INFINOX's account page separates the two: no per-trade commission on the STP account, a fixed commission per lot on the ECN account. The page does not give the ECN amount.

The official pages of XS, Axi, Exness and AXIORY do not call any account ECN. Neither does DecodeFX's account types page (decodefx.com).

The account list screens of HFM and XM (captured 29 October 2026) have no ECN wording in their account names or rows either. Whatever the name, the commission column shows whether a fee applies.

The official wording, summarised (checked 29 October to 14 November 2026)
Broker and accountWhat the official page saysCommission
INFINOX ECNConnects directly to liquidity pools; raw pricing and low latencyFixed per lot (no amount stated)
INFINOX STPAll trading cost sits inside the spreadNo per-trade commission
Vantage ECNDirect access to the interbank market; no spread markupJPY 900 (USD 6) round trip
Vantage StandardA spread is added to the interbank rateNo trading commission
Vantage PremiumNo spread markup; the account types page describes it as STPNo trading commission
Monaxa ZeroAccount list shows "ECN" execution. A separate execution page says Monaxa is the counterparty (in English)$3.50 one way
XS Pro / EliteBoth described as direct market access; no requotesPro: free; Elite: 6$ round trip
XMNo ECN or STP wording on the account types screen (captured 29 October 2026). The Zero account shows a tightest spread of 0 pipsZero: $10 per $100,000 traded
HFMThe order execution policy (January 2026) names the company as the execution venue. No per-account method foundZero: FX $6 round trip
ExnessExecution type is market execution. No ECN or STP wording on the pages readOne way on Raw Spread and Zero
AXIORYThe Zero page cites partnerships with local liquidity providersNano: USD 6 round trip
AxiThe accounts page lists spreads and commissions. No execution-model wordingPremium $4.5 / Elite $3.5 round trip
DecodeFXNo ECN or STP wording on the account types page (decodefx.com)PRO: $7 per standard lot (via this site)
The account name does not reveal the commission

Whether a commission applies is not set by the account name. Vantage's Premium account is described as STP with no commission, while Monaxa's Zero account, labelled ECN execution, charges $3.50 one way. Read the commission column, not the name.

Order execution policies (A-book / B-book): what each broker discloses

Putting commissions on one scale: one way, round trip and per amount traded

Three steps: check the unit, convert to round-trip USD, convert to pips
Commission units and the round-trip USD reading
Broker and accountUnit shownRound-trip USD (1 lot)
XS Elite6$ round trip$6.0
HFM ZeroFX $6 round trip per standard lot$6.0
Axi Premium$4.5 round trip$4.5
Axi Elite$3.5 round trip$3.5
Vantage ECNJPY 900 (USD 6) round trip$6.0
DecodeFX PRO (via this site)$7 per standard lot (official page: $5 round trip)$7.0
AXIORY NanoUSD 6 round trip$6.0
Monaxa Zero$3.50 one way$7.0 (3.50 x 2)
Exness Raw SpreadUp to USD 3.50 one wayUp to $7.0
Exness ZeroFrom USD 0.05 one wayFrom $0.10
XM Zero$10 per $100,000 tradedCheck one way or round trip on the official page
INFINOX ECNFixed per lot; no amount shownNot calculated

On a standard EUR/USD lot (100,000 units), 1 pip is worth 10 US dollars. A $6 round-trip commission equals 6 ÷ 10 = 0.6 pips.

Yen pairs need a currency conversion

On one standard USD/JPY lot, 1 pip is 1,000 yen. If the commission is in dollars, convert it to yen first.

  • Quoted one way: Monaxa and Exness. Double it for a round trip
  • Quoted round trip: XS, HFM, Axi, Vantage, DecodeFX and AXIORY
  • Quoted per amount traded: XM. Check on the official fee page whether it is one way or round trip
  • No amount shown: INFINOX. The official account page gives no commission amount

Total cost, commission included: compare two accounts at the same broker

Diagram: $3.5 equals 0.35 pips, $4.5 equals 0.45, $6 equals 0.6, $7 equals 0.7

Break-even works one way. The commission account comes out cheaper only if its spread is narrower by more than round-trip commission ÷ 10 pips.

Table comparing a commission-free and a commission account at the same broker, EUR/USD one lot
EUR/USD, one standard lot, round-trip total (from official values)
BrokerCommission-free (shown spread x $10)Commission account (spread x $10 + round-trip commission)Difference
XSPro, average 0.7 → $7.0Elite, average 0.1 → $1.0 + $6 = $7.0$0.0
HFMPro, from 0.6 → $6.0Zero, from 0 → $0 + $6 = $6.0$0.0
AxiStandard 0.68 → $6.8Premium 0 + $4.5 = $4.5 / Elite 0 + $3.5 = $3.5-$2.3 / -$3.3
VantageStandard, from 1.5 → $15.0ECN 0.0 + $6 = $6.0-$9.0
DecodeFX (via this site)STD, from 0.34 → $3.4PRO 0.0 + $7 = $7.0+$3.6
MonaxaPro, from 0.9 → $9.0Zero 0.0 + $7 (3.5 x 2) = $7.0-$2.0
ExnessPro, from 0.1 → $1.0Raw Spread 0.0 + up to $7 = up to $7.0Up to +$6.0
XMStandard, tightest 1.0 → $10.0Zero, tightest 0 + commission ($10 per $100,000 traded; one way or round trip unclear)Not calculated
INFINOXSTP, from 0.9 → $9.0ECN, from 0.2 → $2.0 + commission (amount not shown)Not calculated
AXIORYStandard 0.5 pips = JPY 500 (USD/JPY)Nano 0.2 pips = JPY 200 + USD 6 (JPY 900 at an assumed JPY 150) = JPY 1,100+JPY 600

※ AXIORY uses the pips and round-trip commission of its official USD/JPY cost example; the JPY 150 rate is our own assumption. Exness uses the USD 3.50 one-way maximum. DecodeFX uses the setting via this site. XM (unit) and INFINOX (amount) are not calculated because the official pages do not make them clear

XS and HFM come out equal. Axi, Vantage and Monaxa show a lower total for the commission account. At DecodeFX (via this site), Exness and AXIORY the commission-free account shows lower.

XM and INFINOX are not totalled, because the official pages do not make the commission unit or amount clear.

Shown values are only a guide

"From" is a best case and "average" is a mean, so the types are mixed. The real total changes with trading hours and the pair.

Monthly commission (round-trip commission x lots; illustrative)
Round-trip commission5 lots a month20 lots a month100 lots a month
$3.5$17.5$70$350
$4.5$22.5$90$450
$6$30$120$600
$7$35$140$700

Forex spread comparison: official figures and commissions

Commission weighs more with volume. Check the other account terms too

Bar chart: $6 round trip is $30 at 5 lots a month and $600 at 100 lots

A $6 round trip is $30 at 5 lots and $600 at 100 lots a month. At low volume, both the commission total and the spread gap stay small, so they decide less.

Terms to check on a commission account (checked 29 October to 14 November 2026)
What to checkOfficial examples
LeverageVantage ECN: up to 1,000x. INFINOX: up to 1:1000 on both STP and ECN. AXIORY Nano: 1,000x. HFM Zero: 1:2000. Monaxa Zero: up to 1:2000. XM Zero: up to 500x (Standard and Micro: 1000x)
Bonus eligibilityXM Zero is not eligible for the deposit bonus (checked 29 October 2026)
Minimum depositMonaxa Zero: $200 (Standard: $15). Axi Premium: $500 first deposit; Elite: $25,000. XM Zero: from $5
EAs and scalpingMonaxa describes Zero as for scalping and EAs; Vantage says EAs can be used on ECN; INFINOX describes ECN for EA and scalping traders. The terms decide what is allowed

Scalping rules by broker

A checklist before you choose an account

Six checks before choosing a commission account
  • Unit: one way, round trip or per amount. Read the official commission column
  • Conversion: round-trip USD, then divide by 10 for EUR/USD pips
  • Comparison: put the same broker's commission-free account next to it, total against total
  • Figure type: from, average or tightest
  • Terms: minimum deposit, leverage, bonus eligibility, EA and scalping rules
Loss risk

Leveraged FX and CFD trading can lose the money you deposit. A low commission does not prevent losses.

How to choose a forex account type

Frequently asked questions

Q. What is the difference between an ECN and an STP account?

A. Of the 10 brokers we list, INFINOX and Vantage are the ones whose official pages use both names. INFINOX says the STP account has no per-trade commission and the ECN account has a fixed commission per lot. At Vantage, the ECN account costs JPY 900 (USD 6) round trip, while the Premium account is described as STP with no commission. Other brokers use the names differently, so judge by the commission column and the spread.

Q. Is a commission account cheaper than a commission-free one?

A. Using shown values that mix "from" and "average", XS and HFM come out equal. Axi, Vantage and Monaxa show a lower total for the commission account. DecodeFX (via this site), Exness and AXIORY show lower for the commission-free one. XM and INFINOX are not totalled, because the official pages do not make the commission unit or amount clear.

Q. Is the commission quoted one way or round trip?

A. It varies. XS, HFM, Axi, Vantage, DecodeFX and AXIORY quote round trip; Monaxa and Exness quote one way. XM quotes $10 per $100,000 traded, so check its fee page for one way or round trip. INFINOX's official account page gives no ECN commission amount.

Q. When is the commission charged?

A. XS notes that the round-trip commission is charged in one sum when the position opens. The other brokers' pages we read do not say when it is charged, so check the trade history.

Q. How much is the INFINOX ECN commission?

A. INFINOX's official account types page says only that a commission applies, fixed per lot, and gives no amount. Our broker page shows "from $5 per lot" (checked 14 August 2026) without saying one way or round trip. It may vary with account setup, so confirm it before opening an account.

Q. Are commission accounts suited to scalping and EAs?

A. Monaxa describes its Zero account as for scalping and EAs, INFINOX describes its ECN account for EA and scalping traders, and Vantage says EAs can be used on its ECN account. What is allowed is set by each broker's terms rather than by the account type.

Q. Do commission accounts need a higher minimum deposit?

A. It depends. Axi Premium needs $500 first and Elite $25,000; XS Elite needs USD 500. HFM Zero starts from $0, XM Zero from $5 and Vantage ECN from USD 50, the same as some commission-free accounts.

Q. Can the commission change?

A. AXIORY says Zero account commissions may be adjusted slightly with market conditions, Vantage notes that details may change without notice, and INFINOX says commission may vary by account setup. DecodeFX commissions depend on the IB contract: the official PRO page shows $5 round trip and the setting via this site is $7 per standard lot. Check the current amount before opening an account.

Sources and conditions

Where to confirm the current conditionsThis column was edited on 14 November 2026 from the official sources above and FX Textbook listing data. Trading conditions, offers and applicable terms can change; confirm the current terms in each broker's official client area before you act.
Important risk information

FX Textbook is an independent information site, not a broker or provider of personal investment advice. Forex and CFDs involve risk. You may lose some or all of your invested capital. No trading result is guaranteed.

NEXT STEP

Compared the commissions? Now check each broker's account terms.

The 10 brokers' account types and minimum deposits are listed in one place.

See the broker list →

Brokers covered in this column

Account types, trading conditions and current offers are on each broker page.

BROKER INFORMATIONXS: account options and conditionsBROKER INFORMATIONXMTrading: account options and conditionsBROKER INFORMATIONHFM: account options and conditionsBROKER INFORMATIONAxi: account options and conditionsBROKER INFORMATIONVantage Trading: account options and conditionsBROKER INFORMATIONDecodeFX: account options and conditionsBROKER INFORMATIONINFINOX: account options and conditionsBROKER INFORMATIONMonaxa: account options and conditionsBROKER INFORMATIONExness: account options and conditionsBROKER INFORMATIONAXIORY: account options and conditions

Compare featured brokers on one basis →

More columns on this broker

FX BASICS · 15 November 2026Start Forex on Your Phone: ID Photo, MT5 Login, First OrderFX BASICS · 15 November 2026Forex Account Base Currency: JPY or USD for Japan ResidentsBROKER COMPARISON · 15 November 2026Opening an Additional Forex Account: Limits and Type ChangesBROKER COMPARISON · 14 November 2026Forex Brokers by Goal: Small Deposits, Bonuses, Low Cost and EAsBROKER COMPARISON · 8 November 2026Axi swap points: how to check them, rollover time, triple-swap day and Nikkei 225 financingBROKER COMPARISON · 8 November 2026AXIORY prohibited trading: hedging, arbitrage, stop hunting and penalties explained by Terms clause
← Back to columnsNews & updates →